Cerulean Room Music Postmortem
Check out our game
Check out the OST (which includes spoilers)
Full Walkthrough, if you want to see things in action without having to solve it all yourself.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oor9eIErnVQ
This LD @alexrose and I made our 29th jam game together. We were joined by @haywirejo on art/design and @masterofdittos on sound effects to help up make an homage to the Crimson Room series of games. Both of them killed it. It's always fun to bring on new collaborators and come away with something we're happy with. Also props to our voice actors (@chrissiecodes, @sheepolution, @coleslaughter, and PaperbatVG), we're thankful to have friends who are willing to jump in and give us some great performances while they're busy with their own jam games.
Anyways...
Music as Information
Thanks to @masterofdittos jumping in on SFX, I was able to only focus on music and voice acting processing this time around. We wanted a range of different eras of technology in our game (telegram, phonograph, cassette player, game boy), and have music reflective of those different eras. We wanted the music to be used as guidance/solutions in the puzzles, so we had to make sure that any gameplay needs were expressed in the songs. Finding ways to do that that felt clear but not obnoxiously on-the-nose was tough, especially since I wanted to make sure it still felt musical. Alex and I debated for far too long about the first morse sequence - a three-tone pattern was easier to make musical, but would have made it a bit too easy for a player to accidentally enter. Eventually we got the four-tone pattern we settled on and I was able to find a balance I was happy with.
Vaudeville
Fairly early on, we settled on wanting Vaudeville-style music playing on the record. Vaudeville isn't a style I'm SUPER familiar with, watching Marx Brothers movies growing up is probably my closest point of reference. So I spent a fair amount of the weekend listening to a bunch of different songs and watching different instruction videos on stylistic traits. So much of Vaudeville is about the bounce and they micro-rhythm, so I also spent a good chunk of time in Reason's Groove Editor micromanaging how much swing and dynamics to add to the instruments (especially the piano). The song played straight would WORK, but it wouldn't have sounded good. Those details were crucial for the vibe.
Also related to details, I spent good chunk of the weekend practicing the guitar line for one of the songs (which is low in the mix, but it's THERE). I wasn't going to get live piano, but I added live guitar and ukelele to give some organic elements. But I also wanted to not do paint-by-numbers TOO much. I ended up writing all of the instrumentation for both songs first and held off on trying to have any vocal melodies. The tone and vibe of vocals is as important as melody in my mind, so I grabbed a phone-microphone (Old Tech!) that my friend made and used that to help me feel the tinny vocals while I was recording. Singing through the phone definitely had an impact on how I ended up piecing the melodies together.
For recording/production, I set up a condenser mic and walked around the room until I had the right amount of space for the guitar and ukelele tracks. Any records from this era were snapshots in a room, so I wanted to make it sound like they existed in space. Vocals needed to sound up-front and kinda distorted in that old direct-to-vinyl way, which I was able to mimic through the phone mic. I added some reverb, vinyl crackles, and EQ to thin things out and it ended close to the vibe I had wanted.
Rap
For the cassette, I had wanted to do an 80s synthy/industrial/Depeche-mode style cover, but as the needs became clearer we settled on doing a rap track that sampled the original Vaudeville version of the song. By the time you hear rap track, you've probably heard the song it samples a couple times. It should feel recognizable, not just musically, but also in what it's trying to communicate to the player. Alex and I went back and forth on a bunch of the details on this song. I heard the phrasing one way, he heard it another. I added a piano line that didn't sit well with him and got in the way. I did too much on it early on and we stripped things WAY back. We ended up with samples from the original song, drums, bass, and vocals. Anything else got in the way more than helped.
Conclusion
All told, there's only a couple minutes worth of music in the game, but it took more than the usual amount of effort to hit the target. The reception has been really positive and it feels like the extra time and effort was worth it.
Source: ldjam.com archive