Caverns of Mal'Dur

by suvi
co-authored: @jkyd
Overall★★★★★★★★★★3.36
Fun★★★★★★★★★★3.14
Innovation★★★★★★★★★★3.57
Theme★★★★★★★★★★3.26
Graphics★★★★★★★★★★3.07
Humor★★★★★★★★★★2.41
Mood★★★★★★★★★★2.75
Uncover long-lost civilizations and prepare your findings in time for the Archaeology Symposium. Laying tiles to maximize adjacency-based score will help you stand out amongst your peers.

*Full-Screen for full-enjoyment & scroll to zoom-in.* Descriptions of excavated cards might give you hints regarding the most lucrative adjacency bonus' -- try to max your high score, uncover the most successful civilizations, bring Dr. Smith to shame! Reading the tiles is recommended, both for atmosphere and strategy.

WARNINGS: May require multiple runs to maximize enjoyment(i.e. rogue-like). After all, much learning is required to become a professor.

We are committed to fixing bugs! Comment below with any issues and we will put our best effort towards fixing the problem. Upgrades/suggestions gratefully accepted.

Change Log


_2021-04-28_
* we now have LEGIBLE FONTS -- wahoo!
* increased size of cards in player's hand

Comments36

squirmonkey27 Apr 2021, 04:10
Aw man, this one looks cool but I don't have a mac or linux to play it on :( big sad.
teenythanos
teenythanos27 Apr 2021, 04:39
Shoot, this link doesn't work! But I am a SUCKER for hexagons so please tag me when it's fixed?? I want to play this!
superpokeunicorn
superpokeunicorn27 Apr 2021, 04:41
Link seems to be broken. Possible that you didn't select the "publish" setting on itch.io.
SirDuck27 Apr 2021, 04:47
using the webgl I appear unable to get past the tutorial. It looks cut off. Good luck!
suvi
suviauthor27 Apr 2021, 04:58
@sirduck fixed the tutorial page scaling -- should work correctly
--027 Apr 2021, 05:12
Looks super intriguing but unfortunately, I can't seem to get past the tutorial page. Clicking on the Start Run button doesn't do anything either in or out of fullscreen mode and it doesn't seem like pressing any keys has any effect either.
LDJam user 236651
LDJam user 23665127 Apr 2021, 05:18
Fun optimization puzzle game! However, I think the fonts are rather difficult to read, and I somehow managed to get the remaining moves to a negative number, preventing me from submitting my archaeological discoveries.
superpokeunicorn
superpokeunicorn27 Apr 2021, 05:22
A very interesting concept! I like the idea of a card game where you don't actually know what all the cards do and have to figure it out via experimentation and reasoning. It was fun trying to puzzle out what all the interactions were, and I was quite surprised when I actually got negative points from certain bad interactions. I did notice that the turn limit counter seems to be broken when I was playing. It started at 0 and counted down into the negatives infinitely. Despite this issue, I had a good time with this game. Nice work!
jkyd
jkyd27 Apr 2021, 05:25
@Lancival Thank you for the feedback! We'll add that to the bug list :)
jkyd
jkyd27 Apr 2021, 05:31
@superpokeunicorn Exactly what we were striving for! Not the bug-- we're working on a fix & hopefully will update soon. Thank you again!
suvi
suviauthor27 Apr 2021, 05:41
@$162477 @lancival @superpokeunicorn Would not have noticed these issues without your feedback, thanks! I updated the intro screen and tutorial to scale with the screen size. Also, suuuperrr face-palm of a bug -- the turn count should not be negative anymore!
PD Dev
PD Dev27 Apr 2021, 06:05
Really cool game idea, I enjoyed playing this. Also like the small icons, they look great! Could do with some background music, though.
--027 Apr 2021, 06:07
Glad to see that you got it fixed, it was worth the wait!
jkyd
jkyd27 Apr 2021, 06:14
@pd-dev Couldn't agree more! funny that @suvi does music, but we ran outta time... ah, next time, right?
jkyd
jkyd27 Apr 2021, 06:15
@--0 thanks!
sarssol27 Apr 2021, 07:45
Pretty fun, but I found the text a bit difficult to read at times.
Squidsheep27 Apr 2021, 11:13
Cool submission, though I found myself struggling to read the cards on hand to to how small they were.
Flatgub
Flatgub27 Apr 2021, 12:45
Although I struggled with some of the fonts (the end of run font was particularly hard for me) I still really enjoyed trying to figure out the adjacency bonuses through experimentation! It could've benefited from a little ambience or sound but overall I did quite enjoy how figuring out where to place my cards made me think quite hard! Well done!
squirmonkey28 Apr 2021, 00:56
Hey we got a web build!

Okay, so as others have said, the font choice here is a big problem. For a game that has so much text, you want a crystal clear font, and that's missing here.

The game bills itself as an archaeology game, but that's not really what happens here, its more like a city builder. You have to place districts near other districts that give them a bonus, until you find the "go deeper" tile. That's cool, but it makes the theme feel a little distant from the gameplay.

I liked how the tiles would kinda hint at what needed to go near them. A lot of times with this sort of game you just have to guess and the developer is like "duh anyone would know that temples and markets go together" but players don't know that by default, so good on you for making it a kinda puzzly thing.

I didn't understand why I'd want to go deeper. Are there better tiles down there? I don't know. Moreover, I didn't really understand how I could influence how fast I got deeper. It seemed to mostly depend on whether I got tiles that drew more tiles or not.

Some eerie exploration music would have helped the mood

Overall, nice game idea, good job making it in the time, it has a very clean and polished look!
jkyd
jkyd28 Apr 2021, 04:56
@squirmonkey Thanks for the awesome feedback!

Yeah, you hit the nail on the head with the importance of legible fonts for text-heavy games, and we'll definitely be changing those (questionable) font choices asap.

The "A Way Down" tiles offer other ways of increasing your final score -- implicitly by allowing you to start uncovering a new lost-civilization (which will reset the deck/board and your hand), as well as explictly adding a civ bonus to your final score for every "A Way Down" discovered. Since the number of turns remaining act as a resource, it's up to you whether it'd be more lucrative to spend them uncovering more tiles in the current civ, or trying your luck on another floor with a refreshed deck/hand. The game does heavily lean on the player piecing together tile synergies accross multiple runs, so hope this clears things up!
Foursay
Foursay29 Apr 2021, 07:13
The system is a bit differnet to understand at first but I still got my time learning it. Nicely designed game!
Hoeleboele29 Apr 2021, 07:15
I was a bit confused about where I needed to place my tiles down to get some extra score. I do love the creating a city aspect and the theme you weaved into it. Overal it feels and plays smooth just a bit more polish and it would be a game I would startup again.
obrunomarques30 Apr 2021, 08:34
Cool game , I like it. Very clever approach to the theme
juxipolo2 May 2021, 03:02
I didn't see the "A Way Down" card in my first run - is the deck random and I got unlucky or is there a condition that has to be met to unlock that card?
suvi
suviauthor2 May 2021, 05:51
@juxipolo The deck is fixed, there is only one "A Way Down" card, so you just got unlucky on your first run. Sometimes it be like that. ¯\\_(ツ)_/¯
krexor3 May 2021, 09:32
I really liked that you did know what cards and combinations gave you points and that you had to do it by trial and error. I never managed to find the way down.

Good game.
AndideBob
AndideBob3 May 2021, 12:16
This was super cool and I think it would work really well as a board game. I think that it should be a bit clearer what each tile does in relation to other tiles, because placing a tile and loosing 10 points seems kind of harsh. But I do like the mechanic of saving your points by going down!

Honestly this was one of the most thought through games I have seen so far, and I wish there was a form of multiplayer here. I see so much potential in this game, I really hope you go further with it and turn it into a fun little puzzle game with maybe some nice story attatched!
jkyd
jkyd3 May 2021, 17:53
@krexor Glad you liked it! Bummer, sometimes excavations just don't have more to uncover -- better luck at the Symposium next time ;)
jkyd
jkyd3 May 2021, 18:29
@andidebob Thank you so much! We definitely had to simplify numerous aspects of the game for the jam, sacrificing clarity or initial intent/balance in the process. However, we now have a pretty strong idea of where we want to go from here, and have already started working on a more fleshed-out version we hope to eventually release as, like you said, "a fun little puzzle game".

I gotta say, we were stoked to read your comment -- we have some ideas on adding multiplayer, more puzzle/strategic depth, and of course, a complimentary story. I also spent a whole day messing with paper prototypes, so it's super gratifying to see the board game aspect shine through!
Shigor
Shigor12 May 2021, 22:10
Simple but nice hex.... I guess builder is much more fitting than archeology "simulation".
Definitely could use description of the tile before you place it (I'm looking at you, battleground) - sure, learning curve and so on, but I'd prefer being able to plan a bit (it would be different if the effect of the tile was partially randomized)
suvi
suviauthor12 May 2021, 23:17
@shigor Thanks for the review! Not sure where you got "simulation" from. The idea behind the game is to discover synergies that are hinted by the text, spelling out all the interactions would take away from the puzzle/exploration aspect. After a few runs, you should be able to play more strategically. Interestingly enough, "battleground" is the second best card in the deck in terms of possible score.

Other games by @suvi

Found a bug?
Tell us on Discord