“By the Book” - Making a puzzle game book for Compo
This post is a postmortem for my LD54 Compo game, CERT - an explorable puzzle book!

From Theme to Ideas
I try not to have any specific plans heading into Ludum Dare, but like most people I have a backlog of old, half-formed ideas. The theme "Limited Space" immediately suggested puzzle mechanics to me, and I was drawn to an old idea of making a puzzle book that the reader could “explore” in the fashion of modern puzzle games like Lingo or The Witness. I was wary at first - packing puzzles aren't traditionally well-loved - but a puzzle book seemed like an opportunity to do them in a fun and unique way. A game built on paper also offered a way to explore fantastical environments and complex scenes that wouldn’t be feasible within the budget of a digital game. Of course the theme also suggested elements of the game's setting and lore, which it uses in less than subtle ways!

Day One - Design and Puzzles
First, I focused on defining the puzzles. The packing puzzles in The Talos Principle were super unsatisfying; I wanted to make sure I could do better. I started with some ideas from paper puzzles like Battleships and Statue Park; I also bought in some mechanics from other genres, like Star Battle. I really wanted to drip-feed the player with mechanics, so they could return to previously-impossible puzzles later with new knowledge, a format that's sometimes called a “metroidbrainia” game. Alongside this I designed out the structure of the book, how the paths would branch and rejoin. I focused on the hub puzzle and the path clues, since those were the most important parts of the game.

As the first day went on I figured out the overall story and the set pieces I wanted to include. I started filling out the text, the puzzles and the dictionary all in parallel, mostly following the order the player is expected to experience them. And of course I slipped in some secrets along the way! The puzzles were super hard to design, due to conflicting requirements; each one needed to be a packing puzzle with a unique solve path, but it also needed a solution word that matched what was happening in the story, background text that made (some sort of) sense, and a [redacted]. Inevitably some of the puzzles ended up skirting some of these requirements a little....

Day Two - Artwork and Testing
By the end of day one the graphic design and almost all of the prose was done, but a few of the hardest puzzles and all of the art still remained. I really wanted to get the game tested before publication, so the number one priority on day two was to get the remaining puzzles finished. That was done about nine hours before the deadline, and after shuffling around the paragraphs to make it a proper adventure game book, the game went out for test (with absolutely zero art).
Fortunately I had fairly clear pictures in my mind at this point of how each set piece should look, so I was able to dive straight into making the artwork. With six pieces to do I budgeted an hour for each; roughly 50 minutes with pen and paper, a quick scan with the phone, then 10 minutes finishing up digitally. Fast art pen work can look a little rough, but here the space theme came to my rescue; inverting the same drawing can make it look much more fancy. You just need to remember to do your shading and lighting in negative!

Testing came back with a few small issues to fix, but for the most part it was a green light. One more round of polish and the book was ready for export, with two hours to spare before the compo deadline.
Conclusions
Overall I think I’m very happy with how everything came together? Making a game book brought in its own unique challenges and new required skills, but removing the need for programming and audio design allowed me more time to focus on the remaining elements of the game, and I think made for a better final product. I hope people enjoy it!
If you're interested, you can print the game using the provided PDFs, or play through it online here!
Source: ldjam.com archive