My 29th Ludum Dare's Postmortem: "Trivia Hart in: Caption Obvious"

"Dateline Ludum Dare 60. I just tracked down the whereabouts of Jack Featherworthy and tossed him in the slammer. It's time to review how the case went."

Giving out more goofy awards

During the previous Ludum Dare, I made a small "award" for every game I played and rated. That was a lot of fun, so I decided to do it again! Here are the awards I drew this time:

LD60_Awards.png

Once again, I love how I can look at these and remember exactly what game I drew it for. Though I do wish I played a few more games this time around.

Anyway, let's talk about my LD60 submission using the following bullet points:

  • From Theme to Concept
  • A Splash of Shadercode
  • Immediate Thoughts
  • Reflection Pool
  • The New Lesson

From Theme to Concept

As we all know, the theme was Old Tech. I was struggling to come up with an idea until I remembered a stupid joke I came up with. The joke being to recreate the style of a silent film, intertitle cards and all, yet still have sound. Imagine a man walking into a bar, audibly saying "What's going on?" and still have the title card appear saying "What's going on?" in white text on a black field. Now imagine if that was a game.

Okay- so how do you turn that idea into gameplay? Well, what if you had to collect the title cards? Like deck building, but all the cards are the captioning! And you use these to solve puzzles. Boom. That's the plan. Talk with the locals, pick up new cards, and use them on other locals to get more cards, which eventually lead you to solving the mystery.

I decided to make a sequel to my Ludum Dare 58 entry, thus expanding on the "Trivia Hart" cinematic universe. I was thinking about making this game entirely in black and white, fitting with the silent film idea, but decided to go for a greyscale plus rose palette.

I also mimicked the style of the original game's title screen. Instead of using the "iconic" trivia hart logo, I stylized the text in the fashion of a title card.

Thumbn.png

That's Caption with an 'O', not Captain. Like Closed Captioning... Yeah, you get it.

A Splash of Shadercode

My favorite screen in the original Trivia Hart game is "Canal Street". A small bridge crosses a canal, while the stream in the foreground reflects the light from the lamps in ribbons, and shines caustics on the wall. The snow in the air glowing from the lamps as well. But as I replay Trivia Hart, I kinda wish the caustics and shimmering water had motion.

Let's focus on the shimmering water. How to give that motion?

Step 1: Distort the image based on some sin waves.

Let's begin with our good friend, the UV square, and slide around the UV coordinates based on some sin waves.

Waves_Code.PNG
Waves1.png

I also make the "Ripple" value weaker near the top of the image, which acts like a bit of parallax so make the offset smaller the further away the part of the image appear to be.

Applying a real texture to it, looks like this!

Waves2.png

To be honest, that doesn't look that great. The pixels are all askew! The next step was to make the UV coordinates aligned to the pixel grid.

Waves_Code2.PNG
Waves3.png

Much better. I can also re-use this effect for the background of the boss fight, and it looks like something out of Earthbound.

Now for the caustics. If you squint your eyes, voronoi noise kinda already looks like caustics. We can apply the same tricks we did earlier, and a little bit of math:

Caustics1.png

I whipped up a look up table for the color palettes, and made the noise get darker the further away it is from a focal point, and we're looking really good!

CausticsLUT.png

And here's how it looks in-game

Shader_Result.png

Another small detail, though it's not a shader, is the subtle "film shake" I made for the title cards.

I added a subtle screen shake, and text dimming. The real objective was to make it look like it's coming out of a 100 year old projector. I specifically made sure this happened around 5 frames per second. I figured that was a good rate to make sure the effect was subtle, noticeable, and not annoying or making it difficult to read.

Immediate Thoughts

I'm happy with how it turned out. I wish I had time for some more music tracks, and I wish I had time to give an idle animation to the acapella group. Other than that, this game turned out pretty much exactly how I hoped. I've also had a lot of people compliment the greyscale + rose palette.

I think the boss fight was a bit rushed and it's pretty obvious. I also wish I had more time for the victory cutscene. I could probably just write multiple paragraphs about what I wish I had more time for, but I'd rather talk about what I learned.

This was my second time making a point and click adventure, so what did I do better this time? Well- somehow the original game had hitbox issues. In an effort to prevent that, I opted for raycast-based collision detection rather than relying on Unity's OnMouseOver() routine. This completely fixed that issue! I also think the fact that this game has a "boss fight" is an improvement over the original game. That being said, I wish I had a goofy ultimatum in this one too. Having the option for the player to arrest the villain or jump in a bottomless pit is and unforgettable joke from the first game.

The original Trivia Hart had 50 lines of dialogue. This one had 75. Not that more dialogue = better game, but it does surprise me looking back on just how many lines I had to record. I think I need some way to add subtitles to these games in the future. In previous games where I added subtitles, the most time consuming part has just been finding a way to sync up the text with the voice lines, needing to add time stamps to some class that prints the subtitles on screen, and it's tedious to set up.

Reflection Pool

During my past several postmortems I've reflected on all the notes I have taken and no-doubt neglected. Let's take a look at my notes and see what I took to heart.

LD59: "Make a Minimum Viable Product early on."

I'll be honest, I did not. I spent the first several hours on art and shaders, then went to sleep. That being said, I actually did have a pretty simple "blueprint" planned out for the game early on. I knew what all the rooms I wanted were, and how they connected. Using some placeholder art, I set up all the rooms and the buttons on screen to move between them. Granted, there was no logic for the puzzles yet, but pretty early on I set up a good skeleton for the game. I also implemented the code for the cards pretty early that day, and the dialogue system for unlocking and using cards. Again, I didn't really make a minimum viable product, but there was a strong foundation by the 24 hour mark, which is more than I can say for the first Trivia Hart.

LD58: "Make a game in a genre you are unfamiliar with."

Right- so making a sequel of a point and click adventure by making another point and click adventure flies a bit in the face of this idea. I did make a card-based combat for the boss fight (Which is something I had never done before), but I didn't have enough time to make anything satisfying come out of that. Even still, I haven't played many point and click adventures, but I'm recalling games like Pajama Sam having mini-games. I don't think I would have had time to add that, but I feel like my Trivia Hart games could use some if I ever expand on the idea further in the future.

LD57: "Scope Smaller, or break the game into small rooms."

You know, I honestly didn't think the scope of this game was too big until it was time to add a boss fight. It took me a very long time to come up with what the boss fight would be, leaving it rushed. I think I have sarcastically chuckled at the notion of "scoping smaller" in every postmortem referencing this one though.

LD56: "Be reasonable with your shader effects."

This tip was born out of a game that had a poorly optimized shader effect destroying the framerate. I know what I'm doing now, and despite having a lot of animated water and caustics, the framerate is stable. Woo!

LD55: "Make sure the camera isn’t jank."

As with the previous Trivia Hart, the camera cannot be jank if there are fixed locations for it.

LD54: “Full in-game tutorial for ANY unique mechanics. It must be explained.”

YES! I genuinely feel like celebrating every time I pull off a good tutorial. This one teaches you about the title card mechanic while also being incredibly funny. Perfect.

LD53: “Get feedback before the deadline.”

Like a broken record, I did not do this one. And for once my roommates were not out of town, so I have no excuse. What would I have learned if people playtested this one before the deadline? Well- I had a hunch that some of the puzzles were a little obscure, so if the player has all the info they need but haven't made progress after four minutes, I had a blinking lightbulb appear next to any characters that could still give you a new Title Card. Wha-boom!! People who immediately figure it out don't feel like they had their hands held in a patronizing way, and people who get stuck have a gentle nudge. Okay, but enough bragging about my incredible foresight. Let's talk about what my foresight missed.

  • I have not seen a single person beat the first round of the boss fight first try. Granted, I didn't have time to implement any form of a punishment for failure, but that's certainly a shortcoming. I pose the simple question, "Blind Tiger is another name for a..." and the answer is among your Title Card collection. "Speakeasy". To be perfectly honest, I only know about this fun fact due to an episode of The Simpsons, (And also the Wikipedia page for Speakeasy). But hey, I'm putting the "Trivia" in "Trivia Hart".
  • A surprising amount of people make it to Fort Featherworthy and assume they will never need to go back to town. I've seen people wander the halls of fort featherworthy for upwards of ten minutes, very clearly lacking the title cards they need, yet not having the curiosity to go back to town?! I wonder if it would be patronizing to add a voice line saying "Hm, I don't think I have the required Title Card."

LD52: “Focus on a single mechanic, and let the story come second.”

I should really retire the second half of that one. As I add more voice acting to my games, the story is a bit important, no? And if I can merge the gameplay and the story in the way that I did here, then I think that's way better than neglecting the story.

LD51: “Voice acting is fun, and I even made an acapella track!”

This was my tenth time adding an acapella track! The important question is, have I improved any? I think I have. It no longer feels awkward to record acapella tracks for my LD Games. I still occasionally have flat notes, or I rush a bit on a specific layer, but it's so much fun.

LD50: “The exhaustion of the 48th hour is real.”

Yeah, it doesn't help that it took me until about four hours before the deadline to realize what I wanted the boss fight to even be. I didn't really plan for the 48th hour, because I think we all hope our games will be ready before that point.

And digging into ye old archives...

LD46: "Focus on the theme, and not what you wish the theme was."

This one is a bit of an elephant in the room. I tend to brainstorm during the theme voting and a losing theme tends to have a really cool idea that I decide to make anyway because it sounds more fun than whatever I come up with for a winning theme. I actually stuck with this advice this time though. I had a much more interesting idea for "Elephant in the Room" than I did for "Old Tech" during the aforementioned brainstorm phase, but I decided to scrap it anyway and stick to the theme. I'm very happy with what I came up with for "Old Tech" and I think this reinforces what I wrote down for LD46.

LD45: "Musical motifs are fun to write, and sound good."

This is something I wish I had more time to work on this Ludum Dare. The music in the first Trivia Hart game has one of the wildest craziest motifs I have ever written. And I just couldn't replicate the magic this time around. I'm still happy with what I wrote, but dang- I need to start learning some real music theory.

LD42: "First impressions matter."

I initially wrote that after my crummy game that opened with a single joke scored top 10 in humor. I haven't thought much about that in the past several years, but you know what? My LD60 game does the same thing. It literally opens with a character audibly saying "Look over there!" followed by the title card of the exact same message appearing. That joke never gets old.

LD41: "Sound effects are super important. Especially for simple feedback like hitting enemies."

This has honestly been something I have been forgetting about. My LD60 game doesn't have sound effects (except for the title card appearing noise) but the gameplay didn't really require it? Perhaps I'm just doubling down on bad practice though. I could imagine a sound effect with every screen transition would work well. I really need more sound effects, don't I?

LD33: "Perhaps spending 20 minutes on art wasn't enough."

I think I chuckled at this note during my postmortem for the first Trivia Hart game. I didn't quite spend 20 hours this time, but I certainly put in a lot of work into the graphics.

The New Lesson

So what advice to I offer to my future self, and anybody reading?

It's hard to put into words. I have felt rather uninspired lately to make games. The news about just how much AI slop was submitted to the Steam Next Fest, or how Claude can clone games in minutes... it's heartbreaking. And it's not just game development that's being poisoned by this. My other hobbies, including emulator development and tool-assisted-speedrunning are being flooded with slop too. And the amount of AI generated content submitted to Ludum Dare, especially the compo, is disgusting. In just the past six months, I have watched so many of my most passion-filled hobbies get completely overwhelmed with uninspiring sludge that was outsourced to an LLM.

But I like programming. I have fun working through the logical puzzles that it demands. I like drawing, and impressing myself when the end result looks beautiful. I like writing music, and the incredibly stupid acapella tracks that I put together. I like writing stories, and shoehorning in the worst jokes I can come up with. And I do all this because I want to improve. I want to be a better artist, and a better musician, and story teller, and programmer. I have been doing the Ludum Dare game jam for eleven years, and look at how much I have grown.

It's not about the ratings, it's about self-improvement.

And if there's a flood of AI-Bros who didn't get the message, then it's their loss.

Results

And now, without a single hint of self awareness, I will flip from saying it's not about the ratings to talking about the ratings.

Results.png

Woah.

The color palette of my thumbnail is ruined.

Thumbn.png

It looks like I just won the Surprise Palette Update award.

SurpriseColorPlatteChange.png

Reflection 2, Conclusion Boogaloo

I know I just ranted a little more than one paragraph ago about it not being about the ratings, but it feels pretty great knowing that the top of overall doesn't have an AI-generated game anywhere in sight. And I obviously wouldn't be in the top 3 if I wasn't still growing as a developer. I was really anxious this time around due to all the generative AI stuff, and I was pretty doom and gloom about seeing Ludum Dare become overwhelmed by it all. I really am afraid of what Ludum Dare will look like in the future if the compo doesn't forbid any form of AI, but I can at least rest easy knowing that passionate art is still beating the alternative. For now.

I'm honestly really happy with how it all turned out. I'm a bit shocked with my 34th place in graphics, but I'm not letting that get me down. Heck, I talked a lot about the graphics and shaders of this game for a reason, and that's because I'm really happy with how it looks. You know what else shocked me? Fifth in fun! That came out of nowhere, considering it's just a point and click adventure! And 77th in theme... that's better than I usually do. I still don't think that's a category you can really optimize though, it just kinda seems like people get it or they don't.

And who could forget the amazing awards my friends gave me?

I won the Funniest Nautical Jump Cut award, given to my by @jeremy-ryan

JeremyAward.png

And the Alcoholic Drinking Fountain Award, given to me by @mathstr0fficial, which I swear made sense in context.

AbiAward.png

This was a doozy. I don't know if I really highlighted this earlier in the postmortem, but this was my tenth time in a row where I added acapella music. TEN TIMES!!! I've taken home another gold in Audio and Humor, as well as my second bronze trophy in Overall. We'll get 'em next time.

With my next Ludum Dare being my 30th, I think I have a lot more reflection in my future. There's an incredible difference between my first Ludum Dare submission and my tenth. And another massive difference between my tenth and twentieth. If I want the 30's era to be a league above the 20's, I'll need to put in the work. Learn some real music theory, genuinely work on improving my art, and I dunno... voice acting lessons? I might have reached the limit of being self-taught in all of my aspects.

Whatever the future holds, I'll still be improving myself. You can't stop me.

☃

Source: ldjam.com archive

Found a bug?
Tell us on Discord